Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.
Bill F., Chappaqua, New York“We have experienced personalized professional service at competitive cost over many years, and have always felt we were in good hands.”
- TMTheresa M., Chappaqua, New York
- JCJoe C., Chappaqua, New York
“Highly recommended.”
- LNLester N., Chappaqua, New York
“I’ve been a client for 31 years. Never have they taken the expeditious route instead of the right way. Quality of service and product has always been in my best interest.”
- Vickie S., Chappaqua, New York
“I love working with Nicolaysen agency. They are always friendly and helpful and have made suggestions to save me money whenever possible.
Always a pleasure to work with them!” - Elena P., Chappaqua, New York
“We’ve had a great experience dealing with Randy and the staff at Nicolaysen! We’ve insured multiple cars and houses with him, and he is always easy to reach, efficient in getting our concerns addressed and pleasant to deal with. We highly recommend him!”
- JBJosh B., Chappaqua, New York
“The people at Nicolaysen are not only knowledgeable and responsive, but also genuinely caring. Randy, Marion, Lillian… they all go above and beyond to help, whatever the need. Very grateful for their coverage.”
- WDWilliam D., Chappaqua, New York
“I have been using Nicolaysen Insurance Agency for 39 years for home and auto insurance, now just auto. That should be enough endorsement. I have always found them helpful.”
- CBConnie B., Chappaqua, New York
“Nicolaysen Insurance Agency personal service to us (Home, Auto) has been outstanding. Assisted us through the process of submitting our claims in a timely and helpful manner.
Customer since 2000” - ABAndrew B., Chappaqua, New York
“always very responsive to any and all situations… for us, these have included some catastrophic events involving trees coming down on our house and/or on our cars… everyone at the agency is friendly and thorough and will make whatever effort is needed to look into any questions that may come up (such as why our insurance premium suddenly increased or what companies could give us comparable coverage at a lower cost)… Nicolaysen has been our insurance agent since we moved here in 1993 and we’ve never had any reason to regret our decision… I’d recommend them to anyone looking for an insurance agency”
- Jonathan J., Chappaqua, New York
“The Nicolaysen Agency has offered our family amazing customer service. When my wife’s car was hit by another driver, who then contested the incident, Nicolaysen was on our side and in constant communication with us and the insurance company. Their dogged support allowed us to come away with the desired verdict. I would suggest them to anyone.”
- GLGary L., Chappaqua, New York
- MMMax M., Chappaqua, New York
“Our experience with Randy Coon at Nicolaysen has been terrific. He is unfailingly prompt in his responses, handles all of our insurance needs in a professional and courteous manner and from time to time offers us valuable suggestions for other matters that he thinks we should consider. And to top it all off, Randy is a pleasure to deal with. We couldn’t be happier.”
- BGBrian G., Chappaqua, New York
“Randy was great to deal with and I’m saving hundreds by using them. Definitely recommend !”
- SASherry A., Chappaqua, New York
“We have been clients of Nicolaysen since 1972.
We highly recommend them for their knowledge, efficiency, friendliness and loyalty to their customers. It is a testament to the company’s stability that people like Marian and Dawn continue to work there since 1972!!
Five stars ⭐️”
